Services
Industries
Free Tools
Resources
About Book a Consultation (407) 694-2055
Orlando, FL · Working nationwide since 2008
Free Tool · No signup

You vs. them: site showdown.

Put your website head-to-head against a competitor's. We grade both on speed, SEO, schema, security, and AI-readiness, then show you exactly where you win and where they are beating you. Free.

Free, no signup. We read both live sites and grade them side by side.

Grading both sites…

See exactly where a competitor is beating you

Ranking is relative. You don’t need a perfect website, you need a better one than the businesses you’re competing with for the same customers. This tool grades your site and a competitor’s side by side so you can see, category by category, where you’re ahead and where you’re losing ground.

What we compare

Both sites are graded on the same six dimensions: Performance (speed signals), Mobile, SEO (titles, meta, headings), Structured data (schema), Security (HTTPS), and AI readiness (can AI engines find and cite you). Whoever does these better, all else equal, tends to win the ranking.

How to use the result

Find the categories where the competitor scores higher, those are your priorities. If they have schema and you don’t, or their site is faster, those are concrete, fixable gaps. The goal isn’t a perfect score; it’s closing the gap with whoever’s outranking you.

Pro tips

  • Compare against the business actually ranking #1 for your main keyword, not just a random competitor.
  • Run a few competitors to spot patterns, if they all have something you lack, that’s your fix.
  • Speed and schema are the two gaps we see win or lose local matchups most often.
  • Re-run it after you make changes to confirm you’ve pulled ahead.

Frequently asked questions

How is the overall grade calculated?
Each site is scored across six weighted categories (speed, mobile, SEO, schema, security, AI readiness), then averaged into an overall grade and score. Both sites use the identical scoring, so the comparison is fair.
Does a higher grade guarantee higher rankings?
No single tool predicts rankings exactly. But the factors graded here (speed, mobile, structured data, crawlability) are real ranking inputs, so beating a competitor on them genuinely helps.
Can I compare any two sites?
Yes, any two public URLs. Many owners compare against the competitor currently outranking them to see what to fix.
Why does my site read as low on H1 or content?
If your site renders with JavaScript, the served HTML can look thin to crawlers. That’s itself worth knowing, and it’s a reason custom-coded, server-rendered sites tend to grade higher.

Want to win that matchup?

If they are beating you, we fix it. If you are ahead, we extend the lead. Get a free audit or a mockup of your better site.

Get a free mockup or audit →Or call/text: (407) 694-2055

What this head-to-head actually compares

This is one grader run twice. Both addresses are fetched at the same moment and scored by identical logic, so neither side gets an easier test: six categories, Performance, Mobile, SEO, Structured data, Security, and AI readiness, each built from specific checks on the HTML the server sends, plus robots.txt and llms.txt from that domain. The screen then shows both letter grades and both scores out of 100, marks the higher overall score as the winner, and lists every category with a mark next to it so you can see which gaps belong to you. On an exact tie, the site you entered first is shown as the winner.

Results are cached by address for 24 hours. That keeps repeat matchups quick, but it also means a change you made this morning may not show in a re-run until tomorrow.

Now the honest part: a win here is not a ranking. This is a snapshot of two pages, and it cannot see who actually ranks for the searches your customers use. It has no view of anyone's backlinks, reviews, Google Business Profile, ad spend, or traffic, and a competitor can grade lower on this page while sitting above you in the map pack because of things the comparison never looks at. It also reads only served HTML, so a JavaScript-heavy site can read thinner than it is. Use it for what it is good at: finding concrete, fixable gaps such as missing schema, a blocked AI crawler, no HTTPS, or a bloated page. The single-site version with the full fix notes is the website report card, and the AIO readiness scanner goes deeper on the AI side.

If I beat a competitor here, does that mean I will outrank them?

No, and the tool does not claim it. What it compares is technical and on-page signals on two pages. Rankings also turn on links, reviews, proximity to the searcher, how complete a Google Business Profile is, and the depth of content across an entire site, none of which appear in this comparison. A better grade means the fundamentals on that page are in better shape, which is worth having on its own terms.

Which competitor should I put in the second box?

Whoever is actually taking the work, meaning the business sitting at the top of the results for the search your customers type, not the shop down the road you think about most. Running two or three of them tells you more than running one, because a gap that shows up against all of them is a pattern rather than a coincidence. Any two public addresses will grade.